But it was working just fine ... until it broke. And why did it break? Did you think it would last forever? And, most important, why do you want to replace it with the same think knowing the first one broke at an inopportune moment?
This review of a carbon water bottle cage sparked a memory of a guy who came by the shop on his ride to buy a replacement bottle cage because his broke mid-ride. The review is really nothing more than a review and not a product test because it represents only one week of use. Come back in one year with how it worked, then that's something.
So, this guy comes in and asks for a bottle cage to replace his broken carbon fiber cage. I show him the King Cage stainless ($18) and their titanium ($60). He asks if I have carbon cages. "No," I say. He asks "why?" I tell him "because they break." Oh yeah. He really wants the King titanium cage because at 29 grams it's in the weight range of carbon cages and is just rad. But he's on a ride and only has a certain amount of cash with him so on goes the stainless cage and off he goes.
A few weeks go by and he comes by again. His other carbon cage broke in the exact same spot - small wonder! He says that he now has his credit card with him and can he exchange the stainless cage for a titanium cage (+ the difference) and buy a second ti cage? Of course! Now he has two outstanding, made in the U.S.A. titanium King cages and does not have to think about them breaking on a ride. And they are hand made by a great guy in Durango, CO. Bonus.
King Cage ti and stainless cages. When you want the best.
(What's playing: E.L.O. Telephone Line)